City of Black and White by Mat Kearney
Reviewed by Susan Lloyd
"Kearney
bares his heart and soul in several songs, writing with an honesty
that is sometimes missing in music that is destined for mainstream
success..."
Mat Kearney’s City
of Black and White is the follow up
to this singer-songwriter’s massively successful second album Nothing
Left to Lose, and Kearney fans will be thrilled to find that while he doesn’t
veer too much from his laid-back punchy acoustic style, he does bring his
music to the next level. According to the bio on his homepage, Kearney’s
been on the road since NLTL hit the airwaves, and the songs he’s chosen
for City of Black and White’s track listing are a reflection of the
time he’s spent touring.
Kearney has a knack for soothing a listener with his distinct voice while
at the same time getting the pulse racing with intricate rhythmic patterns. “Fire
and Rain”, the second song on the album line-up is the perfect example
of that kind of musical command. Kearney’s vocals are solid throughout
while the song slowly builds with a pounding percussion line that doesn’t
overpower and steal the spotlight from poignant lyrics.
It’s easy to forget that a piano is truly a percussive instrument,
but Kearney effectively uses it as such on “Closer to Love” as
the bell-like tones of a piano punctuate the verses. “Closer to Love” also
features a persistent acoustic guitar that isn’t always at the forefront
of the track but peeks out at just the right moments, reminding listeners
that Kearney could perform these songs with just that one instrument and
they would still be solid.
We hear the comfortable strum of the acoustic open “Lifeline”,
and coupled with Kearney’s easy tenor, the song promises to be one
that has impact. Kearney seems to have mastered the ability to relate to
everyman’s struggle, and the lyrics on “Lifeline” prove
that. Kearney finds common ground with his fellow man during this honest
musical conversation about struggling with circumstances, looking for answers,
and maintaining hope. Lyrically, this is the song I find most appealing on
the album.
Kearney does a better than average job with lyrics throughout the majority
of the album, but there are times when things seem a little sub-par in the
poetry department. For example in the stripped down ballad-esque “New
York to California” the song moves along beautifully and paints the
picture of the vulnerability that exists when two people are truly in love
with each other. And while Kearney fits the words and images together throughout
the verses and the chorus, things get dicey on the bridge with “la
la la la la la Oh it’s not too far la la la la la la la Oh to where
you are” making that section of the song seem out of place.
Just two songs later on the track list is the stirring “Annie”.
I love the vibe of the song and there’s something about it that really
feels a lot like something Chris Isaak would write. There’s a drum
backbeat that also whispers of Johnny Cash, but it’s Kearney’s
poetry that really shines on this one. He has such a knack for writing a
song-story, and “Annie” is one of his best.
Kearney bares his heart and soul in several songs, writing with an honesty
that is sometimes missing in music that is destined for mainstream success,
and the acoustic driven “On and On” is probably the most transparent
song in the collection. It may end up being one of my favorites as I listen
more, and it will be a favorite simply because of the honesty that shines
through it.
Kearney has definitely put together an impressive album in City of Black
and White, and I hope it receives the airplay it deserves. “Lifeline” can
be a solid hit on Christian AC radio, and I can see songs like “New
York to California”, “City of Black and White” being mainstream
AC hits. The album feels a lot like something Bruce Hornsby would have put
together in the late 80’s, and reaching back into the archives seems
to be a musical trend across all genres of music that is paying off for artists.
It may be Kearney’s vocal similarities to Coldplay’s Chris Martin
that will cause new listeners to sit up and take notice, but anyone who digs
deeper into Kearney’s song catalog will be won over by his style and
consistency. City of Black and White adds to that catalog in a way that makes
Kearney’s body of work more impressive.